The two fees
- Management fee: a percentage of assets under management (hedge funds) or of committed capital, later invested capital (private equity). Typical: 1–2%.
- Incentive fee / carried interest: a share of profits, often 10–20%.
The traditional “2 and 20” has drifted lower for many funds.
Hurdles, catch-up and high-water marks
- Hurdle rate (preferred return): the return LPs must get before the GP earns an incentive fee.
- Soft hurdle: once cleared, the fee applies to the whole gain.
- Hard hurdle: the fee applies only to the gain above the hurdle.
- Catch-up: after the hurdle, the GP receives most or all of the next profits until its share reaches the agreed percentage of total profit.
- High-water mark: incentive fees are paid only on gains above the highest previous value net of fees. It stops managers from earning fees twice for recovering the same losses.
Work through the mechanics:
A catch-up example
A private equity fund returns a total profit of 30 on 100 committed. The preferred return is 8%, carry 20% with a full catch-up:
- LPs receive the first 8 (preferred return).
- Catch-up: the GP receives the next 2, so it now has 20% of the 10 distributed so far.
- The remaining 20 is split 80/20: LPs 16, GP 4.
Totals: LPs 24, GP 6, exactly 20% of the 30 profit.
Waterfalls
- European (whole of fund): carry only after LPs get all contributed capital plus the preferred return across the fund. LP-friendly.
- American (deal by deal): carry on each profitable exit. GP-friendly, so LPs insist on a clawback to recover excess carry at the end.
Measuring performance
- IRR: the standard measure for private funds, because the GP controls the timing of cash flows.
- Multiple of invested capital (MOIC) and TVPI (total value to paid-in): simple and timing-free.
- Hedge funds report time-weighted returns, net of fees.
Issues to watch:
- Appraisal smoothing understates volatility and correlation.
- Survivorship bias (failed funds stop reporting) and backfill bias (only good track records are added to databases) inflate index returns.
- Leverage magnifies returns and risk.
- Illiquidity means reported values may not be achievable.
Returns should be compared on a like-for-like basis: net of fees, with the same valuation approach.
Exam focus
Compute net returns with management and incentive fees, hurdles and high-water marks, work a catch-up, and explain the biases in reported alternative returns.