Who has a stake
- Shareholders own the residual claim: what is left after everyone else is paid. Their upside is unlimited and their loss is capped at their investment.
- Creditors (bondholders, banks) receive fixed payments. They prefer stable cash flows and conservative policies.
- Board of directors oversees management on behalf of shareholders.
- Managers run the company day to day.
- Employees want pay, security and good conditions.
- Customers and suppliers want fair terms, reliable products and to be paid.
- Governments and regulators want taxes, compliance and a stable economy.
Two views of the company’s purpose
Shareholder theory: the company should maximize the value of shareholders’ claims, within the law. Other groups are protected by contracts and regulation.
Stakeholder theory: the company should balance the interests of all stakeholders. Environmental, social and governance (ESG) considerations draw on this idea.
Where interests clash
Shareholders versus managers
Managers are agents of shareholders (principals), but they may:
- build empires to raise their pay and status;
- avoid risk to protect their jobs, rejecting good projects;
- entrench themselves with anti-takeover defences;
- focus on short-term results that drive bonuses.
Controlling versus minority shareholders
A family, founder or parent company with a controlling stake can elect the board and approve related-party transactions that benefit it. Dual-class shares, which give some holders more votes per share, separate control from economic ownership.
Shareholders versus creditors
Shareholders gain from riskier strategies financed with debt, because they keep the upside and creditors share the downside. They may also pay large dividends or take on more debt, which weakens creditors’ position.
Other conflicts
The board may defer too much to the CEO; companies may cut costs at the expense of employees’ safety or customers’ interests; and governments may push for goals that cost shareholders.
Spot the conflict
Exam focus
Name each stakeholder group’s interests, distinguish shareholder from stakeholder theory, and identify the type of conflict in a short case.