The law of one price
Two portfolios that give exactly the same future payoffs must cost the same today. If not, an arbitrageur buys the cheap one and sells the expensive one for a riskless profit, and that trading pushes prices back in line.
Replication
A derivative can be reproduced with the underlying and borrowing or lending:
- Long asset + short forward = a risk-free payment of the forward price at maturity.
- Long forward = long asset + borrowing.
Because the combination is risk-free, it must earn the risk-free rate:
F0(T) = S0 × (1 + r)ᵀ
With S0 = 100, r = 4% and T = 1: F0 = 104.
If the forward were 106, you could buy the asset for 100 (borrowing at 4%), sell it forward at 106, deliver it in a year, repay 104 and keep 2. If it were 102, do the reverse: short the asset, invest the proceeds and buy forward.
Risk neutrality
Notice that the expected return on the asset never appears. Because the replicating position has no risk, any investor, risk-averse or not, would agree on the price. Derivatives are priced as if investors were risk-neutral: discounting expected payoffs at the risk-free rate under adjusted (risk-neutral) probabilities.
Carry costs and benefits
Holding the underlying has costs and benefits that the forward buyer avoids:
- Costs: storage, insurance, spoilage (commodities). They raise the forward price.
- Benefits: dividends, coupons, interest on foreign currency, convenience yield. They lower the forward price.
F0(T) = (S0 − PV of benefits + PV of costs) × (1 + r)ᵀ
or, with continuous rates: F0(T) = S0 × e^((r + c − i)T)
Price versus value
The price of a forward is the fixed price agreed at inception, chosen so the contract’s value is zero. As the spot price changes, the contract gains or loses value:
Value of long forward at t = St − F0(T) / (1 + r)^(T − t)
Try it:
For options, the price paid (the premium) is also the value at inception; it is never zero, because the buyer receives a right.
Exam focus
Explain no-arbitrage pricing and replication, compute a forward price with and without carry, and distinguish a forward’s price from its value.