How a firm decides how much to produce
Every firm, whatever the market around it, follows one rule: keep producing as long as the next unit adds more to revenue than to cost. Profit is highest where marginal revenue equals marginal cost (MR = MC).
Costs come in two kinds. Fixed costs (rent, salaried staff, equipment leases) do not change with output in the short run. Variable costs (materials, hourly labour, energy) rise with every unit. From these we get:
- Average variable cost (AVC) = total variable cost ÷ quantity
- Average total cost (ATC) = total cost ÷ quantity = AVC + average fixed cost
- Marginal cost (MC) = the cost of one more unit. MC cuts through both AVC and ATC at their lowest points.
Breakeven and shutdown
Two prices matter for a firm that takes the market price as given:
| Price compared with costs | Short run | Long run |
|---|---|---|
| Price ≥ ATC | Operate, profit ≥ 0 | Stay |
| AVC ≤ Price < ATC | Operate, losing less than fixed cost | Exit |
| Price < AVC | Shut down, loss = fixed cost | Exit |
The logic of the middle row trips up many candidates. Fixed costs must be paid whether the factory runs or not. If price covers variable cost with something left over, producing reduces the loss. Shut down only when price can’t even cover the variable cost of each unit.
Move the price in the tool below and watch the firm go from profit, to a loss it should tolerate, to a shutdown.
Economies and diseconomies of scale
In the long run every cost is variable and a firm can choose its size. If long-run average cost falls as output grows, the firm has economies of scale: bulk buying, specialised workers, spreading research costs. If it rises, the firm has diseconomies of scale: layers of management, coordination problems. The output level at the bottom of the long-run average cost curve is the minimum efficient scale.
The four market structures
| Perfect competition | Monopolistic competition | Oligopoly | Monopoly | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Number of sellers | Many | Many | Few | One |
| Product | Identical | Differentiated | Identical or differentiated | Unique, no close substitutes |
| Barriers to entry | Very low | Low | High | Very high |
| Pricing power | None | Some | Some to considerable | Considerable, limited by regulation |
| Long-run economic profit | Zero | Zero | Possible | Possible |
Perfect competition: wheat or a generic commodity. The firm’s demand curve is flat, so P = MR = MC.
Monopolistic competition: restaurants, clothing brands. Each firm’s product is a little different, so it faces a downward-sloping demand curve and advertises. Entry erodes profit in the long run, leaving price equal to ATC but above MC.
Oligopoly: a few large firms, such as airlines or mobile networks, each watching the others. Several models describe their behaviour:
- Kinked demand curve: rivals match price cuts but not price increases, so prices tend to be sticky.
- Cournot: firms choose quantities, taking the rival’s output as given. With more firms the outcome moves toward perfect competition.
- Stackelberg (dominant firm): a leader sets output first and followers react.
- Nash equilibrium: each firm’s choice is best given the others’ choices. Cartels are unstable because each member has an incentive to cheat on agreed output.
Monopoly: one seller, protected by patents, licences, control of a resource or network effects. It sets output where MR = MC and charges the price demand allows. A monopolist can raise profit by price discrimination, charging different prices to groups with different demand elasticity, which can also raise output. Natural monopolies such as water utilities are usually regulated, for example by setting price at average cost.
Measuring concentration
Two measures appear on the exam:
- N-firm concentration ratio: the sum of the market shares of the largest N firms. Simple, but it ignores how share is split among the top firms and does not change after a merger between two of them.
- Herfindahl-Hirschman Index (HHI): the sum of squared market shares (in percent). Four firms at 40%, 30%, 20% and 10% give 1,600 + 900 + 400 + 100 = 3,000. A monopoly scores 10,000. The HHI does respond to mergers among top firms.
Neither measure captures barriers to entry, which matter as much as the current number of firms. A market with two firms and easy entry may behave competitively.
Exam focus
Expect a cost table and a question on whether the firm should operate, a market description to classify, or an HHI to compute. Always compare price with AVC for the short-run decision and with ATC for the long-run one.