Value versus price
Intrinsic value is what a share is worth given its expected cash flows and risk. If your estimate is above the market price, the stock looks undervalued; below, overvalued. Before acting, ask how confident you are, and whether the market knows something you don’t.
Three families of models
- Present value models: value = present value of expected future benefits.
- Multiplier models: value relative to earnings, sales, book value or cash flow.
- Asset-based models: value of assets minus liabilities.
Dividend discount models
The value of a share is the present value of its dividends:
V0 = D1/(1 + r) + D2/(1 + r)² + …
Gordon (constant) growth model:
V0 = D1 ÷ (r − g)
Explore how sensitive value is to r and g:
With D0 = $2.00, g = 5% and r = 9%: D1 = $2.10 and V0 = $52.50. Value is very sensitive to g when g is close to r.
Multistage models handle a period of high growth followed by stable growth: discount each dividend in the high-growth period, then add a terminal value from the Gordon model, discounted back.
Preferred shares: a perpetual preferred is a perpetuity: V0 = D ÷ r. $5 ÷ 8% = $62.50.
Free cash flow to equity (FCFE) models discount the cash available to shareholders rather than dividends, useful for companies that pay little or no dividend.
Multiples
| Multiple | Use |
|---|---|
| P/E | Most common; earnings drive value. Unusable when earnings are negative |
| P/B | Banks and asset-heavy companies |
| P/S | Companies with losses or volatile earnings; sales are hard to manipulate |
| P/CF | Less affected by accounting choices than earnings |
| EV/EBITDA | Comparing companies with different leverage or depreciation policies |
Enterprise value = market value of equity + debt + preferred + minority interest − cash and short-term investments.
Justified forward P/E from the Gordon model = payout ratio ÷ (r − g). With a 60% payout ($2.10 of $3.50 EPS), r = 9% and g = 5%: 0.60 ÷ 0.04 = 15×.
Method of comparables: value a stock at the average multiple of its peers, adjusted for differences in growth and risk.
Asset-based valuation
Value = fair value of assets − fair value of liabilities. Suitable for companies with mostly tangible or financial assets, holding companies, natural resource firms and companies likely to be liquidated. Hard for businesses whose value lies in intangibles.
Choosing a model
Use the model that fits the company’s cash flows and your position: dividends for stable payers and minority stakes, FCFE or FCFF for control or low-payout firms, multiples for quick comparisons, assets for asset-heavy or liquidation cases. Combining several approaches gives a range of values.
Exam focus
Value a share with the Gordon model and a preferred share as a perpetuity, compute a justified P/E, choose an appropriate multiple and know when asset-based valuation applies.