What GIPS is for
Imagine two managers, each claiming 12% a year. One shows every account it runs; the other shows its three best accounts over its three best years. The numbers look equal but mean very different things.
The Global Investment Performance Standards (GIPS) fix this. They are a set of ethical principles for calculating and presenting investment performance in a fair, comparable way. They are created and administered by CFA Institute with input from industry bodies around the world, and they are voluntary: no law requires them, but many institutional clients will only hire firms that comply.
Following GIPS is one good way to meet the performance presentation Standard (III(D)) in the Code and Standards, though that Standard does not require it.
Who can claim compliance
- Firms, defined as the distinct business entity presented to clients. A firm claims compliance for all of its business, not for selected products, offices or people.
- Asset owners, such as pension funds and endowments, can also claim compliance for the way they report their own performance to their oversight bodies.
- An individual manager or a software provider cannot claim compliance.
Compliance is all or nothing. A firm may not say it is “in compliance with GIPS except for…”. It meets all applicable requirements or it does not claim compliance.
Composites
The key tool against cherry-picking is the composite: a group of portfolios managed to a similar investment mandate, objective or strategy.
- Every actual, fee-paying, discretionary portfolio must be in at least one composite.
- Firms may not move portfolios between composites to improve results.
- Performance of the composite is what the firm presents to prospective clients for that strategy.
Non-discretionary portfolios (where client restrictions stop the manager from applying the strategy) are left out of composites.
What a compliant presentation includes
Without memorising every requirement, know the main elements:
- Returns calculated with consistent, prescribed methods, generally time-weighted returns for composites (money-weighted returns are allowed in some circumstances, such as for private equity).
- A measure of the dispersion of returns among portfolios in the composite.
- The composite’s total assets and the firm’s total assets.
- A benchmark, where one is appropriate.
- Disclosures about fees and how the composite is defined.
Verification
Verification is a review by an independent third party of whether the firm’s policies and procedures comply with GIPS on a firm-wide basis. It is recommended but not required. A verified firm can say so; it adds credibility because outsiders have checked the process.
Exam patterns
- “Can a portfolio manager claim GIPS compliance?” No, only firms (and asset owners).
- “Is verification required?” No.
- “Can a firm comply ‘except for’ one requirement?” No.
- “Why composites?” To stop firms from showing only their best accounts.