The capital market line
If investors share the same expectations, the optimal risky portfolio is the market portfolio. The CAL through it is the capital market line (CML):
E(Rp) = rf + [(E(Rm) − rf) ÷ σm] × σp
Portfolios on the CML left of the market are lending portfolios; to the right, borrowing portfolios.
Systematic and unsystematic risk
- Systematic risk affects the whole market: recessions, rate changes, inflation. It can’t be diversified away.
- Unsystematic risk is specific to a company or industry. Diversification removes it.
Because investors can eliminate unsystematic risk for free, the market rewards only systematic risk.
Beta
βi = Cov(Ri, Rm) ÷ σm² = ρi,m × σi ÷ σm
β = 1 means the stock moves with the market on average; above 1, more; below 1, less. Beta is estimated by regressing the stock’s returns on the market’s (the market model: Ri = αi + βiRm + εi).
CAPM and the SML
E(Ri) = rf + βi × [E(Rm) − rf]
The security market line plots required return against beta. Uses: estimating the cost of equity, capital budgeting, and judging whether securities are fairly priced. A stock whose expected return lies above the SML is undervalued; below, overvalued.
Performance measures
| Measure | Formula | Risk used | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sharpe ratio | (Rp − rf) ÷ σp | Total | A portfolio that is the investor’s whole holding |
| Treynor ratio | (Rp − rf) ÷ βp | Systematic | A portfolio that is part of a diversified whole |
| M² | rf + Sharpe × σm − Rm | Total, in % | Comparing with the market in return terms |
| Jensen’s alpha | Rp − [rf + βp(Rm − rf)] | Systematic | Return above CAPM’s prediction |
Sharpe and M² always rank portfolios the same way; Treynor and Jensen’s alpha use beta and can rank differently from Sharpe when portfolios are poorly diversified.
Beyond CAPM
Multi-factor models add other sources of systematic risk, such as size, value, momentum or macroeconomic factors. Arbitrage pricing theory allows several factors without specifying which. CAPM remains the most used because of its simplicity.
Limitations: the market portfolio can’t be observed, beta is unstable, the risk-free rate and equity risk premium must be estimated, and empirical tests give mixed results.
Exam focus
Calculate beta, required returns and alpha; distinguish the CML from the SML; and compute and choose between Sharpe, Treynor, M² and Jensen’s alpha.