Two families of bias
Cognitive errors come from faulty reasoning, memory or information processing. They are easier to correct with better information and education.
Emotional biases come from feelings and impulses. They are harder to change, so advisers often adapt to them.
Cognitive errors
Belief perseverance (holding on to existing beliefs):
- Conservatism: underreacting to new information.
- Confirmation: seeking information that supports one’s view and ignoring the rest.
- Representativeness: judging by resemblance to past patterns or stereotypes, ignoring base rates.
- Illusion of control: believing one can influence outcomes one can’t.
- Hindsight: believing past events were predictable.
Processing errors (how information is used):
- Anchoring and adjustment: sticking too close to an initial number.
- Mental accounting: treating money in separate buckets.
- Framing: decisions depend on how a question is presented.
- Availability: judging likelihood by how easily examples come to mind.
Emotional biases
- Loss aversion: losses hurt about twice as much as equal gains please. Leads to the disposition effect: selling winners too early and holding losers too long.
- Overconfidence: overestimating one’s knowledge or skill. Leads to excessive trading and under-diversification.
- Self-control: favouring spending now over saving for long-term goals.
- Status quo: doing nothing.
- Endowment: valuing what one owns more than the same thing not owned.
- Regret aversion: avoiding decisions that might lead to regret, often by herding or staying conservative.
Classify the bias
Biases and markets
Biases help explain anomalies: momentum (underreaction, then herding), bubbles and crashes (overconfidence, herding), the value effect (overreacting to bad news), and home bias (familiarity). Limits to arbitrage let them persist.
What advisers do
- Moderate cognitive errors by explaining and showing evidence.
- Adapt to emotional biases, especially strong ones in wealthy clients: design a portfolio the client will stick with.
- Use a behaviourally modified asset allocation that balances the ideal portfolio with what the client can live with.
Exam focus
Classify a bias as cognitive or emotional from a short case, name its likely effect on decisions, and say whether to moderate or adapt.