The commodity universe
- Energy: crude oil, natural gas, refined products.
- Grains: wheat, corn, soybeans.
- Softs: coffee, cocoa, sugar, cotton.
- Livestock.
- Precious metals: gold, silver, platinum.
- Industrial metals: copper, aluminium, nickel.
Each has distinct drivers: weather and seasons for agriculture, global growth for metals, geopolitics and inventories for energy. The life cycle of a commodity (planting to harvest, extraction to refining) shapes the timing of supply.
The futures curve
- Contango: futures price > spot price; upward-sloping curve.
- Backwardation: futures price < spot price; downward-sloping curve.
Theories:
- Insurance theory (Keynes): producers hedge by selling futures and pay speculators a premium, so the curve is normally backwardated.
- Hedging pressure hypothesis: both producers and consumers hedge; the side with more pressure determines the shape.
- Theory of storage: futures price = spot + storage costs − convenience yield. High inventories → contango; scarcity → backwardation.
Sources of return
Total return = price return + roll return + collateral return
- Price return: change in futures prices.
- Roll return: gain or loss from rolling expiring contracts. Positive in backwardation, negative in contango (holding the curve constant).
- Collateral return: interest on the margin and cash backing the position.
Swaps and indexes
Swaps: total return swaps, excess return swaps, basis swaps (spread between two prices), variance and volatility swaps.
Indexes differ in:
- breadth of commodities;
- weighting (production value, liquidity, equal or fixed weights);
- roll method (front month vs deferred or optimized rolls);
- rebalancing frequency.
These choices produce very different returns over time.
Exam focus
Explain the futures curve with each theory, decompose commodity returns, and compare commodity swaps and index designs.