Forms of payout
- Regular cash dividends: steady and expected; cuts are taken badly.
- Special (extra) dividends: one-offs from unusual cash.
- Liquidating dividends: returning capital.
- Stock dividends and splits: more shares, same total value.
- Share repurchases: open market, tender offers, Dutch auctions, direct negotiation.
Theories
- Dividend irrelevance (Modigliani-Miller): in perfect markets, payout policy doesn’t affect value; investors can create their own “dividends” by selling shares.
- Bird-in-the-hand: investors value certain dividends over uncertain capital gains.
- Taxes: where dividends are taxed more than gains, investors may prefer low payouts.
- Clientele effect: investors pick companies whose payouts suit their tax and income needs.
- Signalling: initiations and increases signal confidence; cuts signal trouble.
- Agency costs: paying out cash prevents managers wasting it, but can transfer wealth from bondholders to shareholders.
Payout policies
- Stable dividend: smooth increases towards a target payout; a common model is ΔD = (target payout × E − D_prev) × adjustment factor.
- Constant payout ratio: dividends move with earnings.
- Residual dividend: fund positive-NPV projects with the target capital structure first; pay out the rest.
- Global trends: fewer companies pay dividends in some markets, and buybacks have grown.
Buybacks and EPS
Rules:
- EPS rises if the earnings yield (E/P) exceeds the after-tax cost of funds.
- If shares are bought above book value per share, BVPS falls; below, it rises.
- A buyback at fair value doesn’t change shareholder wealth, just as an equal dividend wouldn’t (ignoring taxes and signals).
Is the dividend safe?
- Payout ratio = dividends ÷ earnings; high ratios leave little cushion.
- Dividend coverage = net income ÷ dividends.
- FCFE coverage = FCFE ÷ (dividends + buybacks).
- Balance sheet strength, cyclicality of earnings and capital needs.
Exam focus
Compare dividend theories, choose the right payout policy, compute the EPS and BVPS effects of a buyback, and assess dividend safety.