Types of corporate restructuring
Investment actions:
- Equity investment (minority stake), joint venture, acquisition (control).
- Divestiture: selling a business.
- Spin-off: shares of the subsidiary distributed to parent shareholders.
- Equity carve-out: subsidiary shares sold to the public, the parent keeps control.
- Split-off: shareholders exchange parent shares for subsidiary shares.
Financing actions: leveraged recapitalizations, buybacks, deleveraging, liability management.
Reorganizations: cost restructuring, bankruptcy and reorganization, business model changes.
Motives
- Synergies: cost savings (overlapping functions) and revenue gains (cross-selling).
- Growth, access to technology or markets, vertical integration, market power.
- Tax benefits, use of excess cash.
- Questionable motives: diversification (shareholders can diversify themselves), managerial empire building, bootstrapping EPS.
Valuing a target
- Comparable companies: trading multiples of peers, then add a takeover premium.
- Comparable transactions: multiples paid in past deals; already include control premiums. Few truly comparable deals, and market conditions change.
- Discounted cash flow: project the target’s free cash flows including synergies and integration costs; discount at the target’s risk-adjusted rate.
Use several approaches and check what each implies about synergies.
Who gains
- Target gain = premium = price paid − target’s pre-deal value.
- Acquirer gain = synergies − premium.
Method of payment:
- Cash: acquirer shareholders bear all synergy risk and keep all upside.
- Shares: target shareholders become part-owners and share the risk of overpayment. Acquirers who think their shares are overvalued prefer to pay in shares.
Evaluating a restructuring
Ask:
- Is the strategic rationale sound?
- Are synergies realistic, and what will integration cost?
- What does the deal do to leverage, EPS and the credit rating?
- How does it change the company’s risk and valuation?
Exam focus
Classify restructurings, assess motives, value a target with three methods, and split deal gains between acquirer and target shareholders.