Why regulate
Markets fail in two main ways that regulation tries to fix:
- Informational frictions: one party knows more than another. Examples: securities disclosure rules, licensing of advisers.
- Externalities: costs or benefits not reflected in prices. Pollution is a negative externality; basic research a positive one.
Other goals: protecting consumers and investors, financial stability, competition, and fairness.
Who regulates and how
- Legislative bodies pass statutes.
- Regulatory agencies issue administrative rules and enforce them. Some are independent of government.
- Courts create judicial law through decisions.
- Self-regulating organizations (SROs) set rules for members under oversight.
Tools:
- Price mechanisms: taxes (including Pigouvian taxes on externalities) and subsidies.
- Restricting or requiring activities: bans, licences, capital requirements, minimum standards.
- Disclosure requirements.
- Public provision of goods and services.
- Competition policy: blocking mergers, breaking up monopolies, preventing abuse of market power.
Problems with regulation
- Regulatory capture: the regulator ends up serving the industry.
- Regulatory arbitrage: firms exploit gaps or differences between jurisdictions.
- Regulatory competition: jurisdictions compete with lighter rules to attract business.
- Unintended consequences: for example, rules that raise compliance costs may entrench large incumbents.
- Costs of compliance and of administration.
Classify the issue
Regulation and analysis
For a regulated industry, ask:
- How does regulation affect revenue (price caps, permitted activities)?
- How does it affect costs (compliance, capital requirements)?
- Does it create barriers to entry that protect incumbents?
- What risks come from pending or possible changes?
Exam focus
Identify the market failure a rule addresses, classify regulatory tools, recognize capture and arbitrage, and describe how regulation affects an industry’s economics.