Value and price
- Intrinsic value: what a fully informed investor would pay.
- Mispricing: intrinsic value − market price.
- Perceived mispricing = (estimated value − true value) + (true value − price). Your estimate can be wrong too.
Active investing assumes markets are not perfectly efficient: prices converge to value over time, but not always quickly.
Definitions of value
- Going-concern value: the business continues operating.
- Liquidation value: assets sold off. Orderly liquidation is worth more than a fire sale.
- Fair market value: price between willing, informed, unpressured buyer and seller. Used in tax and legal contexts.
- Investment value: value to a particular buyer, including that buyer’s synergies.
- Fair value (accounting): price to sell an asset or transfer a liability in an orderly transaction.
The valuation process
- Understand the business: industry, competitive position, strategy, quality of financial reports.
- Forecast performance: top-down (economy → industry → company) or bottom-up.
- Choose a model suited to the company and purpose.
- Convert forecasts to value, with sensitivity analysis and adjustments (control premium, marketability discount).
- Apply the conclusions: recommendation, fairness opinion, investment decision.
Choosing a model
| Model | Suits |
|---|---|
| Dividend discount | Stable payers, minority stakes |
| Free cash flow | Companies with little or no dividend, control perspective |
| Residual income | Companies with no dividend and negative FCF, reliable book values |
| Multiples | Quick comparison with peers |
| Asset-based | Holding companies, resource firms, liquidation scenarios |
| Sum of the parts | Conglomerates |
Communicating the valuation
A research report should present the investment thesis, key assumptions, the valuation, a recommendation and the main risks, distinguishing facts from opinion.
Exam focus
Separate estimation error from true mispricing, match a definition of value to its context, and choose the right model for a company.