Case: Corvane Industries
Corvane, a mid-sized industrial company, pays a dividend of $1.20 (D0) and has 100m shares. Analyst Priya Raman gathers:
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Book value per share | $18.00 |
| Expected ROE (long-run) | 13% |
| Cost of equity | 10% |
| Dividend growth (long-run) | 4% |
| FCFE next year | $1.50 per share, growing 4% |
| Peer forward P/E | 14× |
| Corvane EPS next year | $2.30 |
Q1. Value using the Gordon growth DDM.
V = 1.20 × 1.04 / (0.10 − 0.04) = 1.248 / 0.06 = $20.80.
Q2. Value using FCFE.
V = 1.50 / 0.06 = $25.00. Higher than the DDM because the company pays out less than its free cash flow.
Q3. Value using a single-stage residual income model, with residual income growing 4%.
RI₁ = (0.13 − 0.10) × 18 = 0.54. V = 18 + 0.54 / (0.10 − 0.04) = 18 + 9.00 = $27.00.
Q4. Value from the peer P/E, and which value is most reliable?
14 × 2.30 = $32.20. FCFE ($25) is more reliable than the DDM for a company paying out much less than its free cash flow; RI ($27) is similar. The peer multiple is higher, perhaps reflecting peers’ faster growth; Raman should check comparability before relying on it.
Exam focus
Apply several models to the same company, explain why values differ and choose the most appropriate one.