Two ways to use multiples
- Method of comparables: value relative to peers or the market. Shows whether a stock is cheap relative to others, not whether the group is fairly valued.
- Method based on forecast fundamentals: a justified multiple from a valuation model (for example DDM).
Price multiples
| Multiple | Advantages | Drawbacks |
|---|---|---|
| P/E | Earnings drive value; widely used | Negative or volatile earnings; accounting choices |
| P/B | Book value stable, often positive; suits financials | Ignores intangibles; affected by accounting and buybacks |
| P/S | Sales rarely negative, hard to manipulate | Ignores costs and margins |
| P/CF | Less affected by accruals | Definition of cash flow varies |
| Dividend yield | Part of total return | Ignores growth from retained earnings |
Normalize earnings for cyclicals (average over a cycle or ROE × book value). Remove non-recurring items.
Justified multiples
From the Gordon model:
Leading P/E = (1 − b) ÷ (r − g)
Trailing P/E = (1 − b)(1 + g) ÷ (r − g)
P/B = (ROE − g) ÷ (r − g)
P/S = (E/S)(1 − b)(1 + g) ÷ (r − g)
Example: ROE 15%, r 10%, g 6%: P/B = 2.25. Higher ROE relative to r means a higher P/B.
PEG = P/E ÷ growth (%). Assumes a linear relationship between P/E and growth; ignores risk and growth duration.
Enterprise value multiples
EV = market value of equity + debt + preferred + NCI − cash and investments
EV/EBITDA suits capital-intensive and leveraged companies. EBITDA ignores capital spending needs, so compare with EV/EBIT or FCF where capex matters.
Averaging multiples
Use the median or harmonic mean, which reduce the effect of high outliers. P/Es of 10 and 40: harmonic mean 16, arithmetic mean 25.
Relative value in practice
Compare a stock’s multiple with peers, adjusting for growth, risk and profitability differences. Check the industry and market multiple against history: a whole sector can be overvalued.
Exam focus
Compute justified multiples, pick the right multiple for a company, compute EV and harmonic means, and interpret relative valuations.