How private companies differ
Company-specific: earlier life cycle stage, smaller size, overlap of owners and managers, weaker reporting and governance, short-term focus or long-term family view.
Stock-specific: illiquid shares, restrictions on transfer, concentrated ownership.
Purposes and standards of value
- Transactions: sales, financing, venture capital. Usually investment value to a specific buyer.
- Compliance: tax and financial reporting. Usually fair market value or fair value.
- Litigation: damages, disputes.
Normalizing earnings
Adjust for:
- owner compensation above or below market;
- personal expenses run through the company;
- related-party leases or transactions not at market terms;
- non-recurring items;
- discretionary spending cuts before a sale.
Example: owner pay $300,000 vs market $180,000 → add back $120,000 to pre-tax earnings.
Strategic buyers may also include synergies; financial buyers typically don’t.
Approaches
Income approach:
- Free cash flow (FCFF or FCFE) with a multi-stage forecast.
- Capitalized cash flow: single-period FCF ÷ (r − g). Simple; suits stable companies.
- Excess earnings method: required return on working capital and fixed assets; excess earnings capitalized as intangible value.
Discount rates: CAPM with relevered peer betas, or build-up: rf + equity premium + size premium + company-specific premium. Consider the buyer’s financing and lack of access to public markets.
Market approach:
- Guideline public company method: peers’ multiples, adjusted for size, growth and risk, plus a control premium if valuing control.
- Guideline transactions method: multiples from deals; already reflect control.
- Prior transactions in the company’s own shares.
Asset-based approach: fair value of assets minus liabilities. For holding companies, resource firms, early-stage or failing businesses.
Discounts and premiums
- Control premium (DLOC): controlling stakes are worth more. DLOC = 1 − 1/(1 + control premium).
- Discount for lack of marketability (DLOM): estimated from restricted stock studies, pre-IPO transactions or put option pricing.
Total discount = 1 − (1 − DLOC) × (1 − DLOM)
Exam focus
Normalize earnings, choose between income, market and asset approaches, build up a discount rate, and combine control and marketability discounts correctly.