Case: Brightwater Research
Elena Park, CFA, covers retailers at Brightwater, a broker-dealer.
- Park visits a supplier’s warehouse and notices unusually low inventory of a client retailer’s products. Combining this with public data, she lowers her estimates.
- Brightwater’s investment bankers are pitching the same retailer. A banker asks Park to “hold off” on publishing the downgrade.
- Park phones her five largest institutional clients with the downgrade an hour before the firm-wide release.
- Park’s son owns shares in the retailer; she does not disclose this.
Q1. Fact 1: violation?
No. Her observation is non-material, non-public information combined with public data: the mosaic theory.
Q2. Fact 2: what should Park do?
Refuse. Independence and Objectivity: research must not be influenced by banking interests. She should publish when the research is ready, and the firm should have firewalls between research and banking.
Q3. Fact 3: violation?
Yes: Fair Dealing. Changes in recommendations must be distributed so all clients have a fair opportunity to act, not to a favoured few first.
Q4. Fact 4: violation?
Yes: Disclosure of Conflicts. A family member’s holding in a covered company is a conflict that must be disclosed to her employer and clients.
Exam focus
Work through each fact, name the Standard and the required action, and watch for mosaic-theory and fair-dealing traps.