The Standards that dominate Level II
II(A) Material nonpublic information
- Information is material if it would likely affect the price or a reasonable investor’s decision.
- It is nonpublic until disseminated to the market.
- Mosaic theory allows conclusions drawn from public plus non-material nonpublic information.
- Firms should use firewalls, restricted or watch lists, and review employee trading.
III(A) Loyalty, prudence and care and III(C) Suitability
- Identify the actual client (for a fund: the fund’s mandate).
- Proxy voting is part of the duty: vote in the client’s interest, or explain why a vote isn’t cost-effective.
- Soft dollars (client brokerage) belong to the client and must benefit the client.
III(B) Fair dealing
- Disseminate recommendation changes to all clients simultaneously.
- Allocate trades fairly (pro rata or by a fair, disclosed method), especially IPOs.
- Premium service levels are fine if disclosed and available to all who pay.
IV(C) Responsibilities of supervisors
- Have adequate compliance procedures and make sure they are followed.
- Investigate red flags promptly.
- If compliance is inadequate, decline supervisory responsibility in writing until it is fixed.
V(A) Diligence and reasonable basis; V(B) Communication
- Distinguish fact from opinion in reports.
- Disclose the basic investment process and material changes to it.
- When relying on third-party research or quantitative models, understand them and test their assumptions.
VI(A) Conflicts; VI(B) Priority of transactions
- Disclose all matters that could impair independence: ownership, compensation arrangements, board seats.
- Clients first, then employer, then personal accounts. Blackout periods around recommendation changes.
Disclosure is not a cure-all
Disclosure resolves conflicts but does not make prohibited actions acceptable. Front-running or trading on inside information is wrong even if disclosed.
Try two Level II-style situations
Exam focus
Apply the Standards to detailed facts, especially supervision, fair allocation, soft dollars and conflicts. Know which issues disclosure can fix.