Case: Halden vs Novik
| Halden (IFRS, FIFO) | Novik (US GAAP, LIFO) | |
|---|---|---|
| Revenue | 2,000 | 2,100 |
| Net income | 160 | 150 |
| CFO | 185 | 95 |
| Inventory | 300 | 220 |
| LIFO reserve | — | 60 |
| Total debt | 600 | 500 |
| Pension deficit | 20 | 140 |
| Equity | 900 | 850 |
| Tax rate | 25% | 25% |
Q1. Adjust Novik's inventory and equity to FIFO.
Inventory = 220 + 60 = 280. Equity = 850 + 60 × 0.75 = 895.
Q2. Adjusted debt-to-equity for both, including pension deficits as debt.
Halden: (600 + 20) / 900 = 0.69. Novik: (500 + 140) / 895 = 0.72. Unadjusted, Novik looked less levered (0.59 vs 0.67); after adjustment it is slightly more levered.
Q3. Which company has higher earnings quality?
Halden. CFO exceeds net income (185 vs 160), while Novik’s CFO is only 63% of net income (95 vs 150), suggesting heavier accruals.
Q4. Net margin comparison.
Halden 8.0%, Novik 7.1%. Note that LIFO depresses Novik’s reported profit when prices rise, so part of the gap is accounting, not economics.
Exam focus
Make standard adjustments, recompute ratios and judge earnings quality from a case.