How ETFs work
- Primary market: authorized participants (APs) create ETF shares by delivering a basket of securities (or cash) to the fund, and redeem by returning ETF shares for the basket.
- Secondary market: investors trade ETF shares on exchanges.
When the ETF’s price rises above NAV, APs create shares and sell them; when it falls below, they buy shares and redeem them. This arbitrage keeps prices close to NAV. For international or illiquid underlying markets, the ETF price may reflect information the stale NAV doesn’t.
Tracking
- Tracking difference: ETF return − index return over a period. Usually negative by about the fee.
- Tracking error: standard deviation of tracking differences.
Causes: management fees, sampling instead of full replication, index changes and rebalancing costs, cash drag from dividends, securities lending income (positive), taxes on foreign dividends, and fair-value pricing differences.
Costs
Total cost ≈ annual fee × holding period + round-trip trading cost
Trading costs: commissions, bid-ask spread and any premium or discount paid. Spreads depend on the liquidity of the underlying securities, the ETF’s own volume, market volatility and whether underlying markets are open.
For a long-term holder, the fee dominates; for frequent traders, trading costs dominate.
Risks
- Counterparty risk: synthetic ETFs, securities lending.
- Settlement and liquidity risk: spreads and discounts widen in stress.
- Fund closure risk.
- Complexity: leveraged and inverse ETFs reset daily and drift from the multiple of longer-term index returns.
Uses
Core holdings, tactical tilts, factor (smart beta) exposure, cash equitization, transitions between managers, hedging, liquidity management and access to niche markets.
Exam focus
Explain creation and redemption, distinguish tracking difference from tracking error and list their causes, calculate holding costs and identify ETF risks.