What CME are for
Capital market expectations are forecasts of returns, volatilities and correlations for asset classes over a horizon. Strategic asset allocation depends on them, so consistency across asset classes matters as much as accuracy.
The process
- Specify the expectations needed, their horizon and the investor’s needs.
- Research the historical record.
- Choose the method or model.
- Determine information sources and check data quality.
- Interpret the current environment and set expectations.
- Monitor actual outcomes and revise.
Problems in forecasting
- Limitations of economic data: lags, revisions, definition changes.
- Data measurement errors and biases: transcription errors, survivorship bias, appraisal (smoothed) data.
- Limits of historical estimates: regime changes and non-stationarity.
- Ex post risk can understate ex ante risk: samples without crises look safe.
- Biases in analysts’ methods: data mining, time-period bias.
- Failure to account for conditioning information.
- Misinterpreting correlations (they’re not causation and change over time).
- Psychological biases: anchoring, status quo, confirmation, overconfidence, prudence, availability.
- Model uncertainty.
Economic analysis
Trend growth: labour force growth plus labour productivity growth. Equity returns over the long run relate to trend growth.
The business cycle:
| Phase | Inflation | Short rates | Bonds | Equities |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Initial recovery | Falling | Low, bottoming | Yields bottoming | Rising strongly |
| Early expansion | Stable | Rising | Short yields up | Robust |
| Late expansion | Rising | Rising | Yields rising | Volatile, peaking |
| Slowdown | Peaking | Peaking | Yields peak, then fall | Falling |
| Contraction | Falling | Falling | Strong | Bottoming before recovery |
Monetary policy: the Taylor rule gives a benchmark policy rate. Negative rates and quantitative easing compress yields.
Fiscal policy: deficits and debt affect growth, rates and inflation expectations.
Policy mix and the yield curve:
| Fiscal | Monetary | Curve |
|---|---|---|
| Loose | Loose | Steep |
| Tight | Tight | Inverted |
| Loose | Tight | Flat |
| Tight | Loose | Moderately steep |
International interactions: capital flows, exchange rates and interest rate parity link economies; emerging markets are sensitive to global liquidity.
Exam focus
Describe the CME process, identify forecasting pitfalls in a scenario, and link business cycle phases and policy mixes to asset returns and the yield curve.