Liability-relative allocation
For pensions, insurers and some endowments, success means meeting liabilities. The key measures:
- Surplus = assets − liabilities.
- Funded ratio = assets / liabilities.
- Surplus return = (change in assets − change in liabilities) / initial assets.
Three approaches
| Approach | Idea | Best when |
|---|---|---|
| Surplus optimization | MVO on surplus return and surplus volatility | Simple, single-period view |
| Hedging / return-seeking | Split into a liability-matching bond portfolio and a growth portfolio | Plan has a surplus to put at risk |
| Integrated asset-liability | Optimize assets and liabilities jointly (e.g., banks, insurers) | Firm can adjust both sides |
A plan with a deficit may still need return-seeking assets, accepting more funded-status risk; a well-funded plan can de-risk by increasing the hedging portfolio.
Goals-based allocation for individuals
- List goals: needs (living expenses), wants (a second home), wishes (a legacy).
- For each, set the amount, horizon and required probability of success.
- Choose a sub-portfolio for each from a set of model portfolios: the one with the highest expected return that meets the required probability for that horizon.
- Compute the present value of each goal and add up the sub-portfolios.
Essay practice
Case. A corporate pension is 115% funded. Its liabilities have a duration of 14. Its assets are 60% global equities and 40% intermediate bonds with duration 5. The sponsor wants to reduce the chance of the plan falling into deficit.
Task. Recommend one change to the asset allocation and justify it.
Model answer
Increase the liability-hedging portfolio by moving from intermediate to long-duration bonds (or adding receiver swaps) to raise asset duration toward 14. Today, a fall in rates raises liabilities much more than assets because of the duration gap, so funded status is exposed. With a 15% surplus, the plan can afford to reduce return-seeking assets and lock in its funded status.
Exam focus
Calculate surplus and funded ratio, explain the hedging/return-seeking approach, and build a goals-based allocation from model portfolios.