A method for cases
- List the facts that touch on duties: who benefits, who knows what, who was told what.
- Map each fact to a Standard. Most common: III(A) Loyalty, Prudence and Care; III(B) Fair Dealing; III(C) Suitability; VI(A) Disclosure of Conflicts; VI(B) Priority of Transactions; II(A) Material Nonpublic Information; I(B) Independence and Objectivity.
- Decide: violation or not, and why.
- Recommend the corrective action.
Case 1: The new fund
Lena Hartmann, CFA, launches a small-cap fund at her firm. To build a record quickly she allocates the firm’s best IPO allocations to the new fund rather than to existing small-cap separate accounts with the same mandate. She also tells prospects the fund “has never had a down month” (true, over its six months).
Analysis
- Fair Dealing (III(B)): violated. IPO shares should be allocated fairly among accounts with the same mandate, not steered to the new fund.
- Misrepresentation / Performance Presentation (I(C), III(D)): likely violated. Citing six months without context gives a misleading impression of performance; she should present the full, short record with appropriate context.
Case 2: The research trip
Tomás Rivera, CFA, an analyst, attends a company site visit. The company pays for a charter flight because the site is remote with no commercial service, and offers a weekend golf stay afterwards.
Analysis
- Independence and Objectivity (I(B)): accepting the charter flight is acceptable because no commercial alternative exists; Rivera should otherwise pay his own travel. The golf weekend should be declined, as lavish entertainment could compromise objectivity.
Case 3: Soft dollars
A manager uses client brokerage commissions to pay for a data terminal used for research on client portfolios and also for the firm’s marketing.
Analysis
- Loyalty, Prudence and Care (III(A)): violated for the marketing portion. Client commissions belong to clients and may only pay for research that benefits them. Mixed-use services must be allocated, with the non-research part paid by the firm.
Exam focus
Practise identifying multiple Standards in one case and writing short, fact-based conclusions.