The IPS structure
Objectives
- Return: required (to meet goals) and desired.
- Risk: ability + willingness → overall tolerance.
Constraints
- Time horizon (single or multi-stage).
- Taxes.
- Liquidity (emergency reserves, known expenses).
- Legal and regulatory.
- Unique circumstances.
Risk tolerance
| Factor | Raises ability | Lowers ability |
|---|---|---|
| Wealth relative to needs | Large | Small |
| Horizon | Long | Short |
| Income | Stable, bond-like | Volatile, correlated with markets |
| Spending flexibility | High | Fixed needs |
Required return
Example: needs $120,000 after tax from a $3m portfolio, 25% tax rate, 2% inflation. Pre-tax spending = 120,000 / 0.75 = $160,000 → 5.33%. Required return ≈ 5.33% + 2% (or multiplicatively 1.0533 × 1.02 − 1 = 7.44%).
Essay practice
Case. Ravi Menon, 45, is a surgeon earning $600,000 a year. His $4m portfolio is 40% in the shares of a private surgical-device company he co-founded. He wants to retire at 60, fund two children’s university costs in 5–8 years, and leave money to charity.
Task. Assess his ability to take risk and identify two constraints.
Model answer
Ability: above average. High, stable income, a 15-year horizon to retirement and substantial wealth relative to near-term needs.
Constraints: (1) Liquidity and time horizon: university costs in 5–8 years create a multi-stage horizon and specific liquidity needs. (2) Unique circumstances: the 40% concentrated, illiquid private holding, which may also carry tax and emotional considerations and should be addressed in a diversification plan.
Exam focus
Write each IPS element from case facts, reconcile ability and willingness, and compute required returns.