Types of capital projects
- Going concern: maintaining the business and improving efficiency.
- Regulatory or compliance: required by law, such as safety or environmental upgrades. Sometimes they have negative NPV but must be done.
- Expansion: growing existing businesses or entering new ones.
- Other: projects that don’t fit neatly, such as high-risk research.
Principles
- Decisions use after-tax cash flows, not accounting profit.
- Timing matters: money sooner is worth more.
- Include opportunity costs: what a resource could earn elsewhere.
- Ignore sunk costs: money already spent.
- Include externalities, such as cannibalizing sales of existing products.
- Don’t include financing costs in the cash flows: they are reflected in the discount rate.
Net present value
NPV = −CF0 + CF1/(1 + r) + CF2/(1 + r)² + … + CFn/(1 + r)ⁿ
Accept if NPV > 0: the project earns more than the cost of capital and adds value.
Internal rate of return
IRR is the rate that makes NPV = 0. Accept if IRR > cost of capital. On the BA II Plus, enter cash flows with CF, then press IRR CPT.
Change the cash flows and the discount rate below. The curve is the NPV profile: NPV at every discount rate. Where it crosses zero is the IRR.
For −1,000, 300, 400, 500, 200: NPV at 10% = 115.6, IRR = 15.3%.
When NPV and IRR disagree
For a single independent project with normal cash flows (one outflow, then inflows), NPV and IRR always agree. For mutually exclusive projects, they can rank differently because of differences in:
- Size: a small project can have a high IRR and a small NPV.
- Timing: IRR implicitly assumes reinvestment at the IRR; NPV assumes the cost of capital, which is more realistic.
Choose by NPV. Also, projects whose cash flows change sign more than once can have multiple IRRs or none.
Return on invested capital
At the company level, compare ROIC (after-tax operating profit ÷ invested capital) with the cost of capital. A company earning ROIC above its cost of capital creates value as it invests more.
Common mistakes
- Failing to treat economic responses (competitors reacting) properly.
- Using a template that doesn’t fit the project.
- Pet projects approved because senior managers favour them.
- Basing decisions on EPS or accounting returns.
- Using the company-wide cost of capital for projects with different risk.
- Spending all the capital budget each year because it’s there.
- Generating too few alternatives.
Real options
Projects often contain choices: timing (delay), sizing (expand or abandon), flexibility (change prices or inputs) and fundamental options whose value depends on an underlying price. If NPV without options is slightly negative, valuable options can make a project worth doing.
Exam focus
Compute NPV and IRR, choose between mutually exclusive projects, decide which cash flows belong in the analysis and recognize common biases.