The cost of capital
A company’s investors require a return. The weighted average cost of capital combines those requirements:
WACC = wd × rd × (1 − t) + wp × rp + we × re
Weights should be target proportions at market values. Debt is multiplied by (1 − t) because interest is tax-deductible.
Cost of each component
- Debt: yield to maturity on existing bonds, or the yield on comparable debt; then adjust for tax.
- Preferred stock: dividend ÷ price.
- Equity: usually CAPM: re = rf + β × (expected market return − rf). With rf = 4%, β = 1.2 and an equity risk premium of 5%: re = 4% + 6% = 10%. Alternatives include the dividend discount model and bond yield plus a risk premium.
Example: 40% debt at 6% pre-tax, tax 25%, 60% equity at 10%. WACC = 1.8% + 6.0% = 7.8%.
Factors that shape capital structure
Internal: the business model and its stability; existing leverage; asset types (tangible assets support more debt); corporate tax rate; management’s and owners’ preferences; stage of the life cycle. Start-ups rely on equity; mature, stable companies carry more debt.
External: market conditions and interest rates, regulation, industry norms and credit rating targets.
Modigliani-Miller
Without taxes (and with perfect markets):
- Proposition I: firm value doesn’t depend on capital structure.
- Proposition II: the cost of equity rises linearly with leverage: re = r0 + (r0 − rd) × D/E. Cheaper debt is exactly offset, so WACC stays at r0.
With r0 = 10%, rd = 6% and D/E = 0.5: re = 10% + 4% × 0.5 = 12%.
With taxes:
- Proposition I: VL = VU + t × D. Debt adds value through the tax shield.
- Proposition II: re = r0 + (r0 − rd) × (1 − t) × D/E. With t = 25%, the example gives re = 11.5%, and WACC falls as debt rises.
Adding real-world costs
- Financial distress costs: direct (legal fees in bankruptcy) and indirect (lost customers, suppliers demanding cash, managers distracted). They rise with leverage.
- Agency costs of equity: managers with free cash may waste it. Debt disciplines them, because interest must be paid.
- Agency costs of debt: shareholders of a highly leveraged firm may take excessive risks.
Static trade-off theory: firm value rises with debt until the marginal tax benefit equals the marginal expected cost of distress. That point is the optimal capital structure, where WACC is lowest.
The tool uses a simple illustrative model of how borrowing costs rise with leverage. Real companies estimate it from ratings and spreads.
Pecking order and signalling
Managers know more than investors. Issuing equity can signal that management thinks shares are overvalued; issuing debt signals confidence in future cash flows. So companies tend to prefer:
- internal funds (retained earnings),
- debt,
- new equity last.
Exam focus
Compute WACC and the CAPM cost of equity, state the MM propositions with and without taxes, explain the static trade-off theory and recognize pecking order behaviour.