What efficiency means
A market is informationally efficient if prices adjust quickly and rationally to new information. In such a market, you can’t consistently earn returns above those justified by risk, after costs, using that information.
Two values to keep apart:
- Market value: the price the stock trades at.
- Intrinsic value: the value a well-informed investor would place on it.
Active managers try to find gaps between the two.
What makes markets more efficient
- Many participants, including professional analysts.
- Availability and timeliness of information.
- Freedom to trade, including short selling.
- Low transaction and information costs.
When it costs more to find and exploit a mispricing than it is worth, prices can stay “wrong”. So efficiency is a matter of degree.
The three forms
| Form | Prices reflect | What can’t beat the market |
|---|---|---|
| Weak | Past prices and volume | Technical analysis |
| Semi-strong | All public information | Technical and fundamental analysis of public data |
| Strong | Public and private information | Everything, including inside information |
Evidence suggests developed markets are largely weak- and semi-strong-form efficient. Insider trading studies show strong form does not hold, which is why insider trading is illegal.
Tests use event studies: does the price react fully at the announcement, or drift afterwards? Abnormal return = actual return − expected return given risk.
Anomalies
- Time-series: calendar effects (the January effect), momentum (winners keep winning for a while), overreaction (extreme losers rebound).
- Cross-sectional: the size effect (small stocks outperformed in some periods) and the value effect (low P/B or P/E stocks outperform).
- Other: closed-end fund discounts, post-earnings announcement drift, poor long-run returns after IPOs.
Many anomalies weaken after they are published, are explained by risk factors, or vanish after trading costs.
Behavioural finance
Investors don’t always act rationally:
- Loss aversion: losses hurt more than equal gains feel good.
- Overconfidence: overestimating one’s skill or information.
- Herding: following the crowd.
- Representativeness and mental accounting: shortcuts that distort judgment.
These help explain bubbles, momentum and overreaction. Markets can still be efficient overall if rational traders correct errors, but limits to arbitrage can let biases move prices.
Implications
- Portfolio managers: in efficient markets, focus on diversification, costs and taxes. Active management is a search for the less efficient corners.
- Analysts: research has value where information is costly or slow to spread.
- Technical analysts: in weak-form efficient markets, chart patterns shouldn’t work after costs.
Exam focus
Match a strategy to the form of efficiency that defeats it, interpret an event study result, and name an anomaly or bias from a description.