What an index is
A security market index represents a market or segment with a single number that changes as its members’ prices change. Index providers choose:
- the target market,
- the securities to include,
- how to weight them,
- how often to rebalance,
- how often to re-examine membership.
Price return and total return
A price return index uses only price changes. A total return index also reinvests dividends or interest. For a stock index yielding 2% a year, the two drift far apart over decades.
Weighting methods
- Price-weighted: sum of prices ÷ divisor. Simple, but a stock’s weight depends on its share price, which is arbitrary. Stock splits change weights and require a new divisor.
- Equal-weighted: each stock has the same weight. Gives small companies more influence and must be rebalanced often.
- Market-cap-weighted: weight by price × shares. The most common. Float-adjusted versions use only freely tradable shares. Big companies dominate, and the index can become concentrated in overvalued stocks.
- Fundamental-weighted: weight by sales, earnings, book value or dividends. Tends to tilt toward value stocks.
Same three stocks, same price moves, three different answers. Edit the numbers:
With the starting values: price-weighted +4.1%, equal-weighted +3.3%, cap-weighted +2.0%.
Rebalancing and reconstitution
Rebalancing brings weights back to target. Equal-weighted indexes sell winners and buy losers to rebalance; cap-weighted indexes rebalance themselves as prices move.
Reconstitution adds and removes members. Stocks being added often rise on the announcement as index funds will need to buy them.
Uses
- Gauging market sentiment.
- Proxies for market returns and risk in models such as CAPM.
- Benchmarks for active managers.
- Models for index funds and ETFs.
Types of indexes
- Equity: broad market, multi-market, sector, style (value/growth, size).
- Fixed income: harder to build because of the number of bonds, illiquidity and constant turnover.
- Alternative: commodities (often built from futures, so returns include roll and collateral yield), real estate (appraisal-based, transaction-based or REIT indexes) and hedge funds (self-reported data with survivorship and backfill bias).
Exam focus
Compute price-, equal- and cap-weighted index returns, explain each method’s biases, and know the difference between rebalancing and reconstitution.