Group III is the heart of the Standards: what you owe the people whose money you manage or advise on. There are five Standards.
III(A) Loyalty, prudence and care
You owe clients loyalty and must act with reasonable care and prudent judgment. Client interests come before your employer’s and your own.
Points that come up often:
- Who is the client? For an individual, the person. For a pension plan, the beneficiaries, not the company that sponsors it. For a fund, the fund’s investors, following its stated mandate.
- Soft dollars. Brokerage commissions are paid with client money, so they belong to the client. If you direct trades to a broker in return for research, that research must benefit the clients whose trades paid for it. Using it for your own firm’s general needs is a violation.
- Best execution. Seek the best overall result for clients when trading, not just the lowest commission.
- Proxy voting. Vote proxies in clients’ interest, with a policy and records. Not every routine vote needs deep analysis, but important ones do.
III(B) Fair dealing
Treat all clients fairly when you:
- Send out recommendations or changes to them. Do not tip off favoured clients before others. Distribute changes in a way that gives everyone a fair chance to act.
- Take investment action. When a trade is good for several accounts, allocate it fairly, often pro rata. This matters most for scarce opportunities like hot IPOs.
Fair does not mean identical. A firm may offer premium service levels for higher fees, as long as it discloses them to all clients and the service levels do not disadvantage the rest. Personal accounts and family accounts that are fee-paying clients should be treated like any other client, not better and not worse.
III(C) Suitability
When you advise or manage money for a client, you must:
- Find out the client’s investment experience, objectives (return and risk) and constraints before acting, and update this regularly, at least yearly.
- Usually record it in an investment policy statement (IPS). Constraints include time horizon, liquidity needs, taxes, legal and regulatory factors, and unique circumstances.
- Make sure each investment is suitable for the portfolio as a whole, not just on its own. A risky stock can be fine inside a diversified portfolio.
If a client insists on a trade that is unsuitable, you may carry it out after discussing it, but you should consider whether the IPS needs updating. If you manage a fund to a mandate, suitability means sticking to the stated strategy, not judging each investor.
III(D) Performance presentation
When you show investment performance, make sure it is fair, accurate and complete. Violations include:
- Showing only your best accounts or best periods.
- Presenting simulated or back-tested results as actual results.
- Taking credit for a past employer’s track record without saying so.
Firms commonly meet this Standard by following the Global Investment Performance Standards (GIPS), covered in a later lesson, but GIPS compliance is not required by this Standard.
III(E) Preservation of confidentiality
Keep current, former and prospective clients’ information confidential, unless:
- The information concerns illegal activity by the client, or
- The law requires disclosure, or
- The client gives permission.
Cooperating with a CFA Institute professional conduct investigation is not a breach of confidentiality.
Common exam traps
| Trap | Answer |
|---|---|
| Premium clients get faster calls after a rating change | Violation of fair dealing, unless all clients are told about service levels and nobody is disadvantaged; tipping off before public release is a violation |
| Manager buys a risky asset for a conservative client because it fits a diversified mix | Can be suitable; suitability is judged at the portfolio level |
| Soft-dollar research used to run the whole firm | Violation of loyalty, prudence and care |
| Disclosing a client’s data to the regulator because the law requires it | Not a violation |