Group II protects the fairness of markets. If insiders can trade on secrets or prices can be pushed around, ordinary investors stop trusting the market. There are two Standards.
II(A) Material nonpublic information
You must not act, or cause others to act, on information that is both material and nonpublic.
Material means a reasonable investor would want to know it before deciding, or it would likely move the price. Examples: earnings before release, a planned merger, a big new contract, a regulatory decision, a change in dividend. Vague or stale information usually is not material, and the more reliable the source, the more likely it is.
Nonpublic means it has not been spread to the market in a way investors can act on. A press release, a regulatory filing or a widely available news story makes information public. Telling a few analysts in a private meeting does not.
It does not matter how you got the information: from the company, a friend, an overheard conversation or by accident. If it is material and nonpublic, you must not trade on it and must not pass it on. The right step is usually to encourage the company to make it public, and to stop trading in the security in the meantime.
The mosaic theory
Analysts are supposed to dig. The mosaic theory says you may combine public information with non-material nonpublic information to reach a conclusion, and act on that conclusion, even if the conclusion itself would be material.
Example: you count trucks at a factory, talk to suppliers about general demand and read public filings, and conclude the company will miss its targets. That is legitimate research. Keep records of how you reached the conclusion.
What firms should do
To keep MNPI contained, firms use:
- Information barriers (firewalls) between departments such as investment banking and research.
- Watch lists of companies where the firm may hold MNPI, monitored by compliance.
- Restricted lists of securities that employees may not trade or recommend.
- Limits on proprietary trading while the firm holds MNPI.
II(B) Market manipulation
You must not engage in practices that distort prices or artificially inflate trading volume with the intent to mislead market participants. There are two main kinds:
- Information-based manipulation: spreading false or misleading information, such as a false rumour to move a price, or hyping a stock you plan to sell (“pump and dump”).
- Transaction-based manipulation: trades meant to give a false impression, such as buying and selling between related accounts to make volume look higher, or buying heavily at quarter end to push up a holding’s price.
The key is intent to mislead. Legitimate trading strategies, including those that take advantage of mispricing or provide liquidity, are not manipulation even if they move prices.
Exam patterns
- The source of MNPI never makes it acceptable.
- Disclosure does not cure MNPI violations; making the information public does.
- Analysts’ own field research plus public data is the mosaic theory, which is fine.
- Quarter-end trading to inflate a valuation is a classic manipulation question.