Why they are different
- Systemic importance: failures spread through the financial system.
- High leverage: small asset losses wipe out equity.
- Regulation: capital, liquidity and conduct rules shape decisions.
- Financial assets and liabilities: marked to fair value or carried at amortized cost; earnings depend on spreads and credit losses.
Banks: CAMELS
| Component | What to look at |
|---|---|
| Capital adequacy | Common equity tier 1 (CET1), tier 1 and total capital ratios relative to risk-weighted assets; leverage ratio |
| Asset quality | Non-performing loans, allowance for loan losses and its coverage, concentrations, fair value hierarchy (Level 3 assets) |
| Management capabilities | Governance, risk management, internal controls, related-party lending |
| Earnings | Net interest margin, fee income, efficiency ratio, quality and sustainability of profits |
| Liquidity position | Liquidity coverage ratio, net stable funding ratio, deposit base, reliance on wholesale funding |
| Sensitivity to market risk | Interest rate gap, value at risk, currency exposure |
Other factors: government support, the bank’s mission (for example, cooperative), off-balance-sheet items, segment mix.
Insurers
Property and casualty (P&C): short-term policies, uncertain claims.
- Loss ratio = losses and loss adjustment expenses ÷ net premiums earned.
- Underwriting expense ratio = underwriting expenses ÷ net premiums written.
- Combined ratio = loss ratio + expense ratio. Below 100% = underwriting profit.
- Reserve development (are past reserves adequate?), investment returns, reinsurance and catastrophe exposure.
Life and health: long-term liabilities.
- Interest rate and longevity risk; asset-liability matching.
- Profitability: total benefits and expenses ÷ revenue, return on assets and equity.
- Investment portfolio quality and liquidity.
- Regulatory capital ratios.
Exam focus
Apply CAMELS to a bank, interpret capital and liquidity ratios, and compute and interpret an insurer’s combined ratio.