Two dimensions of quality
- Reporting quality: do the statements faithfully represent the economics?
- Earnings (results) quality: are the earnings sustainable and adequate?
The spectrum runs from high-quality, decision-useful reports with sustainable earnings, through biased choices and non-compliant reporting, down to fictitious transactions.
Evaluating earnings quality
Accruals: earnings = cash flow + accruals. Accruals are estimates and tend to reverse.
Balance-sheet accruals ratio = (NOA_end − NOA_begin) ÷ average NOA
Cash-flow accruals ratio = (net income − CFO − CFI) ÷ average NOA
NOA (net operating assets) = operating assets − operating liabilities. From 500 to 600: 100 ÷ 550 = 18.2%.
Persistence: regress future earnings on current earnings split into cash and accruals; the accrual part is less persistent. Extreme earnings mean revert.
Recurring versus non-recurring items: strip out real one-offs, but question “one-offs” that recur.
Screening models
- Beneish M-score: eight ratios (days sales in receivables, gross margin, asset quality, sales growth, depreciation, SG&A, leverage, accruals). Higher scores signal manipulation risk.
- Altman Z-score: predicts bankruptcy from five ratios. Lower is riskier.
Both are probabilistic and based on past data. Use them to prioritize, not to conclude.
Where problems hide
- Revenue: early recognition, bill-and-hold, channel stuffing, gross vs net, round-trip transactions.
- Expenses: capitalizing operating costs, long depreciation lives, low reserves (warranties, bad debts), pension assumptions.
- Balance sheet: goodwill not impaired, off-balance-sheet obligations, aggressive fair values (Level 3).
- Cash flow: classifying operating outflows as investing, selling receivables, stretching payables, capitalizing interest.
- Related-party transactions and complex structures.
Red flag or not?
Exam focus
Compute accrual ratios, interpret M-score and Z-score results, and identify warning signs in revenue, expenses, the balance sheet and cash flow.