The framework
- Purpose and context: what decision, for whom?
- Collect data: statements, notes, MD&A, industry and economic data.
- Process data: adjust for accounting differences, common-size statements, ratios.
- Analyse: decompose results, compare with peers and history.
- Conclude and recommend.
- Follow up.
Decomposing ROE
ROE = (NI/EBT) × (EBT/EBIT) × (EBIT/Revenue) × (Revenue/Assets) × (Assets/Equity)
If ROE rose only because leverage rose, the improvement is not operational, and risk is higher.
Adjusting for investments in associates
Equity-method income sits in profit, often in or near EBIT, but the related revenue and assets don’t. To see core operations:
- remove equity income from EBIT;
- remove the investment from assets;
- recompute margins, turnover and ROA.
Ask how much of earnings growth comes from associates.
Segment analysis
Compute margins, capital expenditure and asset turnover for each segment. Look for segments where:
- returns are falling while investment is rising;
- one segment’s profits fund losses elsewhere;
- geographic exposure creates currency or political risk.
Earnings quality and cash
Compare operating income with operating cash flow over several years. A persistent gap may come from:
- rising receivables or inventory;
- capitalized costs;
- aggressive revenue recognition.
The cash conversion ratio (CFO ÷ operating income) summarizes this.
Balance sheet adjustments
- Include lease liabilities and pension deficits in debt.
- Review goodwill relative to equity: large goodwill can mean overpayment and impairment risk.
- Look at Level 3 fair values for valuation uncertainty.
Communicating
Conclusions should connect the numbers to the business: what drives returns, whether they are sustainable, what the main risks are, and what would change the view.
Exam focus
Use extended DuPont analysis, adjust for equity-method investments and off-balance-sheet obligations, analyse segments and compare profit with cash flow.