Constraints that bite
Asset size:
- Large investors: economies of scale and access to internal teams, but capacity limits in small asset classes and markets, and market impact.
- Small investors: limited access to private markets and top managers, higher costs, difficulty diversifying.
Liquidity: spending needs, capital calls, margin calls and emergencies set how much must stay liquid. Private assets require pacing commitments.
Time horizon: human capital and liabilities change over time; goals approach and need less risk.
Regulatory and other external constraints: insurers’ and banks’ capital rules, pension funding rules, endowment spending policies, sovereign wealth fund mandates.
Taxes
After-tax return depends on how returns are taxed (income, dividends, capital gains, deferred gains):
After-tax return (all income, taxed annually) = R × (1 − t)
7% at 25% → 5.25%. After-tax risk also falls: σ_at ≈ σ × (1 − t).
Asset location: place highly taxed assets (taxable bonds, high-turnover strategies) in tax-advantaged accounts and tax-efficient assets (index equity) in taxable accounts.
Tax-aware rebalancing:
- Use contributions, withdrawals and dividends to rebalance.
- Harvest losses to offset gains.
- Widen corridors in taxable accounts because trading triggers taxes.
Revisiting the allocation
Review when:
- goals change (retirement, a new liability, a change in risk tolerance);
- constraints change (new regulation, a liquidity event);
- capital market expectations change substantially;
- the asset allocation drifted beyond policy ranges.
Behavioural considerations
Loss aversion, mental accounting, home bias, familiarity and recency can push investors away from the optimal allocation. Goals-based frameworks and clear policies help investors stick to their plans.
Exam focus
Identify the binding constraint in a case, compute after-tax returns, recommend asset location and tax-aware rebalancing, and decide when to revisit an allocation.