Why currencies are hard to forecast
Exchange rates respond to interest rates, inflation, trade, capital flows and sentiment, and these interact. Over months, random-walk forecasts are hard to beat. Managers therefore use several lenses and focus on the direction and size of risks rather than point forecasts.
The parity conditions
| Condition | What it says | Reality check |
|---|---|---|
| Covered interest parity | Forward premium = interest differential | Holds closely (it’s an arbitrage) |
| Uncovered interest parity | Expected spot change = interest differential | Often fails short term: carry trades profit |
| Purchasing power parity | Exchange rates offset inflation differences | Weak short term; a long-run anchor |
| International Fisher effect | Real rates equal across countries | Rough long-run tendency |
Trade, capital flows and policy
Balance of payments. A current account deficit must be financed by capital inflows. Deficits financed by long-term direct investment are more stable than those funded by short-term “hot money”. Watch for a sudden stop: when inflows dry up, the currency can fall sharply.
Monetary policy. Tighter policy raises real rates and usually strengthens the currency.
Fiscal policy (Mundell-Fleming).
| Capital mobility | Expansionary fiscal + tight monetary | Contractionary fiscal + easy monetary |
|---|---|---|
| High | Currency strengthens | Currency weakens |
| Low | Ambiguous (trade deficit worsens, pressure to weaken) | Ambiguous |
Portfolio balance view. Persistent fiscal deficits increase the supply of government bonds; investors eventually demand a higher return or a cheaper currency to keep holding them.
Using it as a manager
- Start from the forward rate (it already embeds the rate differential).
- Ask whether flows, valuation (real exchange rate vs PPP) or policy argue for a different path.
- Size active currency views small relative to their unreliability, or express them through the hedge ratio.
Essay practice
Case. A US manager holds unhedged Australian bonds yielding 4.5% against US rates of 3.0%. The Reserve Bank of Australia unexpectedly raises rates while the US holds steady. Australia runs a modest current account deficit financed largely by long-term direct investment.
Task. State whether the Australian dollar is more likely to strengthen or weaken in the short run, and justify your answer.
Model answer
Strengthen. The unexpected rate rise widens the interest differential in Australia’s favour, attracting capital inflows. Because the deficit is financed by stable long-term investment, there is little risk of a sudden stop offsetting the effect.
Exam focus
Know the parity conditions and their limits. Be able to give the direction of currency effects from monetary, fiscal and capital-flow changes.