Wednesday, November 18, 2026
Data from SEC filings, checked daily
My DeskFree
Public filings, plainly told
Appraisal measures and benchmarks
Summarize with AIChatGPTClaudePerplexityGoogle AIGrokCopilot
CFA® Level III · Performance Measurement · Lesson 4 of 5

Appraisal measures and benchmarks

Sharpe, Treynor, information ratio, M², Sortino and the properties of a valid benchmark.

Written by Sepehr Parsa9 min read

The measures

Measure Formula Use
Sharpe (Rp − rf) / σp Total portfolio
Treynor (Rp − rf) / βp Part of a diversified portfolio
Jensen’s alpha Rp − [rf + β(Rm − rf)] Return above CAPM
Information ratio (Rp − Rb) / TE Active management skill
M² rf + Sharpe × σb Sharpe in % at benchmark risk
Sortino (Rp − MAR) / downside σ Asymmetric returns

Benchmark quality: SAMURAI

  • Specified in advance
  • Appropriate to the manager’s style
  • Measurable
  • Unambiguous (holdings and weights known)
  • Reflective of the manager’s current investment opinions
  • Accountable (manager accepts it)
  • Investable (could be held passively)

Types: absolute return, broad market index, style index, factor model, returns-based, custom security-based (often best), peer group (weakest).

Essay practice

Case. Manager A: return 12%, σ 20%, β 1.1. Manager B: return 9%, σ 10%, β 0.6. rf = 3%. The fund will be the investor’s only equity holding.

Task. Which manager performed better on a risk-adjusted basis? Justify the measure used.

Model answer

Use Sharpe, because the fund is the investor’s whole equity exposure, so total risk matters. A: (12 − 3)/20 = 0.45. B: (9 − 3)/10 = 0.60. B performed better.

Exam focus

Calculate and choose between appraisal measures, and test benchmarks against SAMURAI.

Check yourself

Tap an answer. You get the explanation straight away.

  1. A portfolio returned 10% with σ 16%; the benchmark returned 8% with σ 12%; rf is 2%. The portfolio's M² is closest to:

  2. Which ratio is most appropriate for a hedge fund with negatively skewed returns?

  3. A benchmark chosen after the period is over violates which property?

Questions people ask

When should Treynor be used instead of Sharpe?

When the portfolio is one part of a well-diversified total portfolio, so only systematic risk matters.

Why are peer-group benchmarks weak?

They aren't investable, aren't specified in advance (the peer group changes), and suffer survivorship bias.

What is a capture ratio?

Upside capture compares the portfolio's return with the benchmark's in up markets; downside capture does the same for down markets. A manager with low downside and high upside capture adds value through asymmetry.

Unlimited practiceGenerate more Performance Measurement questionsFresh questions with worked solutions every time, in the Level III style.
Progress is saved in this browser.
Next lesson · 5 of 5Manager due diligenceInvestment process, operational risk, fees and capacity: what to check before hiring a manager.

CFA Institute does not endorse, promote or warrant the accuracy or quality of WallStPal. CFA® and Chartered Financial Analyst® are registered trademarks owned by CFA Institute.

Exam format, timing and topic weights are from CFA Institute's Level I, II and III exam pages, checked November 15, 2026. Check CFA Institute for the year you sit. Lessons and practice questions are WallStPal's own and are not CFA Institute material.

Report an error

Tell us what looks wrong on this page. We check every report against the original filing and fix mistakes on our corrections page.

Share this trade
XTelegram
My Desk · free

Sign in to follow

Follow stocks, members of Congress, famous investors and funds, and see what's new each time you come back.