The measures
| Measure | Formula | Use |
|---|---|---|
| Sharpe | (Rp − rf) / σp | Total portfolio |
| Treynor | (Rp − rf) / βp | Part of a diversified portfolio |
| Jensen’s alpha | Rp − [rf + β(Rm − rf)] | Return above CAPM |
| Information ratio | (Rp − Rb) / TE | Active management skill |
| M² | rf + Sharpe × σb | Sharpe in % at benchmark risk |
| Sortino | (Rp − MAR) / downside σ | Asymmetric returns |
Benchmark quality: SAMURAI
- Specified in advance
- Appropriate to the manager’s style
- Measurable
- Unambiguous (holdings and weights known)
- Reflective of the manager’s current investment opinions
- Accountable (manager accepts it)
- Investable (could be held passively)
Types: absolute return, broad market index, style index, factor model, returns-based, custom security-based (often best), peer group (weakest).
Essay practice
Case. Manager A: return 12%, σ 20%, β 1.1. Manager B: return 9%, σ 10%, β 0.6. rf = 3%. The fund will be the investor’s only equity holding.
Task. Which manager performed better on a risk-adjusted basis? Justify the measure used.
Model answer
Use Sharpe, because the fund is the investor’s whole equity exposure, so total risk matters. A: (12 − 3)/20 = 0.45. B: (9 − 3)/10 = 0.60. B performed better.
Exam focus
Calculate and choose between appraisal measures, and test benchmarks against SAMURAI.