A due diligence checklist
| Area | Questions |
|---|---|
| Philosophy and process | What is the edge? Is it repeatable and consistent with holdings? |
| People | Stability, incentives, key-person risk |
| Performance | Consistent with process? Attribution, capture ratios, drawdowns |
| Portfolio | Concentration, liquidity, capacity, style consistency |
| Operations | Custody, independent valuation, compliance, trade reconciliation, auditors |
| Vehicle and terms | Fees, liquidity terms (lock-ups, gates), transparency |
Errors in selection
- Type I: hiring an unskilled manager (often from chasing recent returns).
- Type II: firing or rejecting a skilled manager after a bad patch.
Investors tend to fear Type II less than they should and make more Type I errors by chasing returns.
Essay practice
Case. A committee wants to fire a manager after two years of underperformance. Attribution shows her stock selection was positive but her value style was out of favour; her process and team are unchanged.
Task. Recommend whether to fire her.
Model answer
Keep her. Underperformance came from the value style, which the committee chose when it hired her, not from a failure of her selection process, which remains positive. Firing her now risks a Type II error and buying high in another style.
Exam focus
Apply the due diligence areas, distinguish Type I and II errors and evaluate fee structures.