The process
- Define the role of each mandate in the portfolio: active or passive, style, risk budget.
- Identify the universe of suitable managers.
- Screen quantitatively: returns, risk, consistency.
- Due diligence: investment and operational.
- Decide and contract: fees, guidelines, reporting.
- Monitor and review.
Type I and Type II errors
Null hypothesis: the manager has no skill.
- Type I error: hiring or keeping an unskilled manager.
- Type II error: not hiring or firing a skilled manager.
Short-term noise makes both likely. Investors tend to worry about Type I errors after poor results, causing frequent manager changes that hurt returns.
Investment due diligence
Qualitative:
- Philosophy: what market inefficiency does the manager exploit, and why will it persist?
- Process: universe, research, portfolio construction, sell discipline, risk management.
- People: experience, stability, incentives, key-person risk.
- Portfolio: do holdings match the stated style?
Quantitative:
- Returns relative to benchmark and peers; attribution; capture ratios; drawdowns.
- Style analysis: returns-based or holdings-based.
- Consistency across market environments.
Operational due diligence
Firm ownership and finances, compliance culture, trading and allocation practices, valuation (especially for illiquid assets), use of independent administrators, auditors and custodians, IT and cybersecurity, business continuity.
Vehicle choice: separately managed account (control, transparency, customization) versus pooled fund (lower minimums and costs, less control).
Fees
- AUM-based: simple, predictable; little link to performance.
- Performance-based: base fee plus a share of returns above a benchmark or hurdle.
- Symmetric fees reward and penalize equally; asymmetric fees reward only.
- High-water marks, caps and clawbacks improve alignment.
- Fee impact compounds over time; compare managers on expected net-of-fee returns.
Exam focus
Distinguish Type I and Type II errors, list investment and operational due diligence items, spot style drift, and evaluate fee structures.