Three steps
- Measurement: compute returns correctly (time-weighted for managers).
- Attribution: explain where active return came from.
- Appraisal: judge whether results reflect skill, adjusting for risk.
Return attribution
Brinson-Fachler (sector-based):
Allocation_i = (wp_i − wb_i) × (Rb_i − RB)
Selection_i = wb_i × (Rp_i − Rb_i)
Interaction_i = (wp_i − wb_i) × (Rp_i − Rb_i)
With 70/30 versus 60/40 and the returns shown: benchmark 7.6%, portfolio 9.0%, active 1.4% = allocation 0.6% + selection 0.4% + interaction 0.4%.
Factor-based attribution: active return = Σ active factor exposures × factor returns + residual (security selection). Fixed income attribution separates yield curve, sector/spread, currency and security effects.
Risk attribution: decomposes active risk into contributions from allocation, selection and factors; check that risk is taken where the manager claims skill.
Benchmarks
Properties of a valid benchmark: specified in advance, appropriate, measurable, unambiguous, reflective of current investment opinions, accountable, investable.
Types: absolute return targets, broad market indexes, style indexes, factor-model-based, returns-based (style analysis), manager universes (peer groups: not investable, survivorship-biased), custom security-based benchmarks.
Alternative investments are hard to benchmark: illiquidity, smoothing, leverage. Use public market equivalents for private equity.
Appraisal
| Measure | Formula / idea |
|---|---|
| Sharpe ratio | (Rp − rf) ÷ σp |
| Treynor ratio | (Rp − rf) ÷ βp |
| Information ratio | Active return ÷ active risk |
| Appraisal ratio | Jensen’s alpha ÷ residual risk |
| M² | Sharpe-adjusted return at the benchmark’s risk |
| Sortino ratio | (Rp − target) ÷ downside deviation |
| Capture ratios | Upside and downside returns relative to the benchmark |
| Drawdown | Peak-to-trough loss and recovery time |
Skill needs a long record, a sound process and consistent results; short records are dominated by noise.
Exam focus
Compute Brinson-Fachler effects, interpret factor and risk attribution, evaluate a benchmark, and choose appropriate appraisal measures.