Wednesday, November 18, 2026
Data from SEC filings, checked daily
My DeskFree
Public filings, plainly told
Portfolio performance evaluation
Summarize with AIChatGPTClaudePerplexityGoogle AIGrokCopilot
CFA® Level III · Performance Measurement · Lesson 1 of 5

Portfolio performance evaluation

Attribution, appraisal measures and benchmark quality.

Written by Sepehr Parsa10 min read

Three steps

  1. Measurement: compute returns correctly (time-weighted for managers).
  2. Attribution: explain where active return came from.
  3. Appraisal: judge whether results reflect skill, adjusting for risk.

Return attribution

Brinson-Fachler (sector-based):

Allocation_i = (wp_i − wb_i) × (Rb_i − RB)
Selection_i = wb_i × (Rp_i − Rb_i)
Interaction_i = (wp_i − wb_i) × (Rp_i − Rb_i)

With 70/30 versus 60/40 and the returns shown: benchmark 7.6%, portfolio 9.0%, active 1.4% = allocation 0.6% + selection 0.4% + interaction 0.4%.

Factor-based attribution: active return = Σ active factor exposures × factor returns + residual (security selection). Fixed income attribution separates yield curve, sector/spread, currency and security effects.

Risk attribution: decomposes active risk into contributions from allocation, selection and factors; check that risk is taken where the manager claims skill.

Benchmarks

Properties of a valid benchmark: specified in advance, appropriate, measurable, unambiguous, reflective of current investment opinions, accountable, investable.

Types: absolute return targets, broad market indexes, style indexes, factor-model-based, returns-based (style analysis), manager universes (peer groups: not investable, survivorship-biased), custom security-based benchmarks.

Alternative investments are hard to benchmark: illiquidity, smoothing, leverage. Use public market equivalents for private equity.

Appraisal

Measure Formula / idea
Sharpe ratio (Rp − rf) ÷ σp
Treynor ratio (Rp − rf) ÷ βp
Information ratio Active return ÷ active risk
Appraisal ratio Jensen’s alpha ÷ residual risk
M² Sharpe-adjusted return at the benchmark’s risk
Sortino ratio (Rp − target) ÷ downside deviation
Capture ratios Upside and downside returns relative to the benchmark
Drawdown Peak-to-trough loss and recovery time

Skill needs a long record, a sound process and consistent results; short records are dominated by noise.

Exam focus

Compute Brinson-Fachler effects, interpret factor and risk attribution, evaluate a benchmark, and choose appropriate appraisal measures.

Check yourself

Tap an answer. You get the explanation straight away.

  1. A portfolio holds 70% in sector A (return 12%) and 30% in B (2%). The benchmark holds 60% A (10%) and 40% B (4%). The allocation effect (Brinson-Fachler) is:

  2. Using the same data, total active return is:

  3. A manager's upside capture is 110% and downside capture is 120%. This means:

Questions people ask

Why might a benchmark be inappropriate?

If it doesn't reflect the manager's style or universe, attribution will show 'skill' or 'failure' that is really a style mismatch. Peer group averages are especially problematic.

What is the difference between returns-based and holdings-based attribution?

Returns-based attribution regresses portfolio returns on factor returns; it needs only return history but is less precise. Holdings-based attribution uses actual positions and is more detailed but misses intra-period trading.

What does a maximum drawdown measure?

The largest peak-to-trough fall in value. It reflects the pain an investor would have suffered and how long recovery might take.

Unlimited practiceGenerate more Performance Measurement questionsFresh questions with worked solutions every time, in the Level III style.
Progress is saved in this browser.
Next lesson · 2 of 5Investment manager selectionDue diligence and fee structures.

CFA Institute does not endorse, promote or warrant the accuracy or quality of WallStPal. CFA® and Chartered Financial Analyst® are registered trademarks owned by CFA Institute.

Exam format, timing and topic weights are from CFA Institute's Level I, II and III exam pages, checked November 15, 2026. Check CFA Institute for the year you sit. Lessons and practice questions are WallStPal's own and are not CFA Institute material.

Report an error

Tell us what looks wrong on this page. We check every report against the original filing and fix mistakes on our corrections page.

Share this trade
XTelegram
My Desk · free

Sign in to follow

Follow stocks, members of Congress, famous investors and funds, and see what's new each time you come back.