The case
A mid-sized corporate defined benefit pension plan:
- Assets $2.0bn; liabilities $2.2bn (funded ratio 91%); liability duration 13.
- Plan open to new members; sponsor is financially strong and wants lower contribution volatility.
- Current allocation: 55% global equity, 30% core bonds (duration 6), 15% private equity and real estate.
- Investment committee meets quarterly; small internal staff.
Step 1: Objectives and constraints
- Return: enough to close the deficit over time with reasonable contributions.
- Risk: sponsor wants lower surplus volatility; ability to take risk is moderate to high (strong sponsor, open plan).
- Liquidity: benefit payments around 4% of assets a year; capital calls from private funds.
- Horizon: long.
- Regulation: funding rules and accounting effects on the sponsor.
Step 2: Diagnose
The biggest risk is the interest rate mismatch: liability duration 13 versus assets’ effective duration much lower. Asset BPV covers only a fraction of liability BPV, so falling rates widen the deficit.
Step 3: Options
- Lengthen bond duration (long government or corporate bonds).
- Add a derivatives overlay (receive-fixed swaps or bond futures) to raise the hedge ratio without selling equities.
- Glide path: raise the hedge ratio as the funded ratio improves.
- Review illiquid allocations against liquidity needs.
Step 4: Recommend
For example: raise the interest rate hedge ratio from about 35% to 60% using long-duration bonds and a swap overlay; keep return-seeking assets for growth; set a glide path to 80% hedging at 100% funded; maintain a liquidity buffer for collateral calls.
Step 5: Implement and monitor
- Choose managers and instruments; set collateral management.
- Monitor funded ratio, hedge ratio, liquidity and manager performance; rebalance to policy ranges.
Exam focus
Work through a case in order: objectives and constraints, diagnosis, options, recommendation with justification, implementation and monitoring.