Motivations and choices
Trades are driven by: new information (alpha), rebalancing, cash flows, risk changes.
Key factors in choosing a strategy:
- Order size relative to average daily volume.
- Urgency / alpha decay: how fast the opportunity disappears.
- Liquidity and volatility of the security.
- Risk aversion: trading slowly reduces impact but increases price risk.
Execution methods
- High-touch: a broker works the order; suits large, complex or illiquid trades.
- Algorithms:
- VWAP / TWAP: follow volume or time profiles.
- Percent of volume (POV): trade a fixed share of market volume.
- Implementation shortfall / arrival price: trade faster early to limit price drift.
- Liquidity seeking: search venues, including dark pools.
- Principal trades / risk trades: a dealer takes the whole block at a known price.
- Program trades for baskets.
Measuring costs
Implementation shortfall compares the actual portfolio with a paper portfolio executed at the decision price:
- Delay cost: price drift between the decision and the order arriving.
- Execution (trading) cost: difference between execution and arrival prices.
- Opportunity cost: price move on shares not filled.
- Fees.
The example totals $46,000, or 92bp of the $5m paper trade.
Other benchmarks:
- Arrival price: price when the order reaches the market.
- VWAP / TWAP: average prices over the trading period.
- Market on close: for trades meant to match closing prices, such as index rebalances.
Market-adjusted cost removes the general market move (beta × market return) to isolate trade-specific cost.
Trade governance
- A written trade policy: best execution, order handling, broker and venue selection, conflicts.
- Trade cost analysis to evaluate brokers and algorithms.
- Fair allocation of trades across accounts.
Exam focus
Choose a trading approach given urgency and size, compute and decompose implementation shortfall, and match benchmarks to trading goals.