Liability-driven investing
Types of liabilities:
| Type | Amount | Timing | Example |
|---|---|---|---|
| I | Known | Known | Bullet bond repayment |
| II | Known | Uncertain | Callable debt, life insurance payout |
| III | Uncertain | Known | Inflation-linked payment |
| IV | Uncertain | Uncertain | Property and casualty claims, pensions |
Strategies
- Cash flow matching: buy bonds whose cash flows match each liability. Simple, no rate risk, but costly and inflexible.
- Duration matching (immunization):
- Single liability: PV of assets = PV of liability; Macaulay duration of assets = horizon; asset convexity slightly above the liability’s (minimize structural risk).
- Multiple liabilities: match money duration / BPV; asset convexity > liability convexity; asset cash flows dispersed around liabilities.
- Contingent immunization: active management while the surplus stays above a floor.
- Horizon matching: cash flow matching for near-term, duration matching for later liabilities.
Using derivatives
Close a duration gap without selling assets:
Futures contracts ≈ (liability BPV − asset BPV) ÷ BPV per contract
Alternatives: receive-fixed swaps to add duration; swaptions for asymmetric protection (a receiver swaption protects if rates fall).
Hedge ratio = asset BPV (including derivatives) ÷ liability BPV. Pension funds often hedge partially, balancing protection against the cost and return given up.
Risks in LDI
- Model risk in estimating liabilities.
- Spread risk: corporate bond assets versus liabilities discounted at a different curve.
- Curve risk (non-parallel shifts).
- Counterparty, collateral and liquidity risk with derivatives.
Index-based strategies
- Full replication: hold every security. Low tracking error; impractical for broad bond indexes.
- Stratified sampling (cell matching): match key characteristics (duration, sector, quality).
- Optimization: minimize tracking error subject to constraints.
- Enhanced indexing: small tilts to add return within tight tracking error.
ETFs, futures and total return swaps offer alternatives with different costs and tracking.
Exam focus
Classify liabilities, choose an LDI strategy, compute the futures needed to close a BPV gap, and compare index replication methods.