Opportunistic Insider Buying
Most insider trades follow a calendar. These purchases did not: the insider has traded every year, but not usually in this month. That is the kind of trade research has tied to future returns.
Latest opportunistic purchases
Routine or opportunistic: what happened next
Every open-market trade on file, three months after the trade date, against the S&P 500 and against the equal-weight S&P 500 (every company in the index at the same weight, the fairer yardstick for the smaller companies insiders mostly buy). For sales, a negative number means the stock did worse than the market after the insider sold. The choice of index moves every row up or down together, so it changes the levels more than the gap between opportunistic and routine; whether the two groups hold different kinds of company is tested further down.
| Kind of trade | Purchases | Median vs S&P 500 | Sales | Median vs S&P 500 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Opportunistic traded in each of the last three years, not usually in this month | 3,630 809 companies | −1.0% | 17,433 | −3.5% |
| Routine traded in this same month in each of the last three years | 2,346 173 companies | −4.9% | 6,896 | −2.6% |
| Not classified too little trading history to tell | 13,518 2,430 companies | −2.7% | 41,105 | −4.6% |
Did the stock just fall?
The same purchases, split by what the stock did in the four weeks before the buy. Stocks that fell hard often bounce in the following months whoever buys them, so an edge that lives only in the first row is partly a rebound anyone could have bought. An edge that holds in the last row is closer to information. Under each median is the median per company, so a few companies buying every month do not count as many separate results.
| Kind of purchase | Stock in the 4 weeks before | Purchases | Median vs S&P 500, 3 months |
|---|---|---|---|
| Opportunistic | Fell more than 15% | 423 180 companies | −5.0% −3.0% per company |
| Fell 0% to 15% | 1,139 408 companies | −0.3% −0.7% per company | |
| Flat or rose | 1,297 396 companies | −1.3% −0.4% per company | |
| Routine | Fell more than 15% | 133 17 companies | −24.4% −4.2% per company |
| Fell 0% to 15% | 849 95 companies | −5.7% −4.1% per company | |
| Flat or rose | 921 93 companies | −4.4% −4.8% per company |
Is it the label, or the kind of company?
Routine buyers may simply sit in different companies: smaller ones, or more banks. If so, part of the gap above is a size or sector effect, not information. Here the same purchases are measured three ways: against the S&P 500, against the company's sector ETF (regional banks against KRE, biotech against XBI, and so on, from the SEC industry code), and against an index of companies its size (IWM under $2 billion in market value, IJH from $2 to $10 billion, the S&P 500 above). Each figure is the median per company, three months after the purchase. Only purchases with all three figures count.
| Stock in the 4 weeks before | Kind | Companies | vs S&P 500 | vs sector ETF | vs same-size index |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| All purchases | Opportunistic | 577 | +0.6% | +2.0% | +0.6% |
| Routine | 112 | −1.8% | +0.1% | −2.2% | |
| Gap | +2.4% | +1.9% | +2.8% | ||
| Fell more than 15% | Opportunistic | 138 | −1.6% | −3.5% | −1.8% |
| Routine | 13 small sample | −4.2% | −10.2% | −4.2% | |
| Gap | +2.6% | +6.7% | +2.5% | ||
| Fell 0% to 15% | Opportunistic | 285 | +1.3% | +1.7% | +1.8% |
| Routine | 59 | −3.3% | −1.5% | −0.6% | |
| Gap | +4.6% | +3.2% | +2.4% | ||
| Flat or rose | Opportunistic | 284 | +1.6% | +2.8% | +0.9% |
| Routine | 61 | −4.5% | −1.7% | −3.9% | |
| Gap | +6.1% | +4.5% | +4.8% |
Gap = opportunistic minus routine, in percentage points. If it holds up against the sector and size benchmarks, the difference is not explained by routine buyers sitting in smaller companies or in banks. The last column is the share of companies in each group that are banks (measured against KRE) and that are under $2 billion in market value.
A lone buyer or a group? A top-up or a big bet?
Two more cuts of the same purchases. Each row is one buy event: one insider, one stock, one trade date. "With other insiders" means at least one other insider of the same company bought within 7 days either side. The size of the bet is the shares bought against the shares the insider already held directly, from the holdings line on the same Form 4; "first shares held" means the insider held none directly before. Every figure is the median per company (each company's own median, then the median of those), three months after the purchase, against the S&P 500. Cells with fewer than 5 companies show no figure.
Alone or with other insiders
| Stock in the 4 weeks before | Buys | Companies | Median per company | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| All purchases | Alone | 10,422 | 2,346 | −1.8% |
| With 1 other insider | 3,108 | 753 | −0.6% | |
| With 2 or more | 5,197 | 625 | −0.3% | |
| Fell more than 15% | Alone | 1,270 | 544 | −2.3% |
| With 1 other insider | 432 | 174 | +1.0% | |
| With 2 or more | 816 | 158 | −4.5% | |
| Fell 0% to 15% | Alone | 3,337 | 1,196 | −1.8% |
| With 1 other insider | 1,020 | 349 | −2.2% | |
| With 2 or more | 1,554 | 283 | −2.1% | |
| Flat or rose | Alone | 3,767 | 1,255 | −1.4% |
| With 1 other insider | 971 | 312 | +0.3% | |
| With 2 or more | 1,518 | 231 | −0.1% |
Size of the buy against the existing stake
| Stock in the 4 weeks before | Buys | Companies | Median per company | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| All purchases | Under 10% added | 8,931 | 1,519 | −0.8% |
| 10% to 49% | 2,414 | 1,126 | −1.1% | |
| 50% to 99% | 637 | 464 | +0.9% | |
| Doubled or more | 711 | 528 | −2.7% | |
| First shares held | 978 | 620 | −4.7% | |
| Fell more than 15% | Under 10% added | 1,174 | 386 | −2.0% |
| 10% to 49% | 371 | 259 | +1.5% | |
| 50% to 99% | 106 | 91 | +1.7% | |
| Doubled or more | 113 | 101 | −4.1% | |
| First shares held | 125 | 101 | −1.6% | |
| Fell 0% to 15% | Under 10% added | 2,903 | 804 | −0.3% |
| 10% to 49% | 761 | 472 | −1.5% | |
| 50% to 99% | 213 | 172 | −1.5% | |
| Doubled or more | 236 | 193 | −4.0% | |
| First shares held | 249 | 190 | −5.8% | |
| Flat or rose | Under 10% added | 3,102 | 771 | −0.6% |
| 10% to 49% | 798 | 465 | −1.0% | |
| 50% to 99% | 202 | 162 | +0.3% | |
| Doubled or more | 214 | 180 | −2.6% | |
| First shares held | 296 | 229 | −5.6% |
All open-market purchases count here, classified or not; the last column keeps only opportunistic buys. A filing can report holdings on more than one line (directly, through a trust, a spouse), so the size test uses the direct line only and leaves out buys made only indirectly.
Planned in advance or not?
Since April 2023 Form 4 has a checkbox for trades made under a Rule 10b5-1 plan, which is set up months ahead. A plan purchase in a stock that has just crashed was decided before the crash, so it says little about what the insider thinks now. Purchases from April 2023 on, three months after the trade, against the S&P 500. Groups under 10 purchases show no figure. Under each count is the number of companies, and under each median the median per company (each company's own median, then the median of those), so a few companies buying every month do not count as many separate results.
| Kind of purchase | Plan | After a drop of 15%+ | Median | All purchases | Median |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Opportunistic | Under a 10b5-1 plan | 5 3 companies · small sample | — | 141 24 companies | +1.8% +5.9% per company |
| No plan | 418 178 companies | −5.3% −3.0% per company | 3,489 795 companies | −1.1% −0.6% per company | |
| Routine | Under a 10b5-1 plan | 44 1 company · small sample | −29.0% | 212 8 companies · small sample | −26.4% −2.5% per company |
| No plan | 89 17 companies | −17.2% −4.2% per company | 2,134 169 companies | −4.0% −3.4% per company |
What "opportunistic" means
Lauren Cohen, Christopher Malloy and Lukasz Pomorski (Journal of Finance, 2012) split insiders by their calendar. An insider who traded in the same month in each of the previous three years is routine: the trade is probably habit, a bonus being paid, or a plan. One who traded in each of those years but not always in that month is opportunistic. Everyone else is left unclassified.
In their data, routine trades were more than half of all insider trades and a portfolio built on them earned essentially nothing extra. A portfolio built on opportunistic trades earned abnormal returns of 82 basis points a month, value-weighted.
What to keep in mind
Our version uses open-market purchases and sales (Form 4 codes P and S), credited to the first reporting owner on each filing. History before our own daily files comes from the SEC's quarterly Insider Transactions Data Sets. The study's results come from decades of past data; a single opportunistic purchase can still go wrong, and the table above is a live check of whether the pattern is holding today.
Source: SEC Form 4 filings on EDGAR and the SEC Insider Transactions Data Sets. Prices are weekly closes adjusted for splits; trades whose filings look mistyped are left out. Not investment advice. See also our study of opportunistic and routine buys and insider buying against the S&P 500.
About this page
WallStPal explains public SEC filings and congressional stock trade reports in plain English. Nothing is for sale; the site is free and supported by ads.
How to read it
- Form 4
- The form a company insider (officer, director or owner of more than 10%) must file with the SEC within two business days of buying or selling the company's shares.
- 13F
- A quarterly list of U.S. stocks held by an investment manager with more than $100 million, filed within 45 days after each quarter ends.
- STOCK Act
- A 2012 law that requires members of Congress to report stock trades by themselves, a spouse or a dependent child within 45 days.
A real example
In January 2016, when bank stocks were falling, JPMorgan Chase CEO Jamie Dimon bought 500,000 JPMorgan shares with his own money, worth about $26 million. His Form 4 made the purchase public within days, and investors read it as a strong sign of confidence.
Explain it like I'm 13
We read the long, boring forms that grown-ups file with the government and tell you what they say in normal words.
Data from public SEC filings and congressional reports. Information, not investment advice. Check every number against the filing linked on the page.